שלום

איזה מהרמקולים שבכותרת יותר איכותיים?

לדעתי ה-ATP3 יותר איכותיים(לא בהרבה) , אבל בשביל חווית סראונד עדיף את ה-Inspire.

ATP3 יותר איכותיים.. בהרבה.. אבל הם "רק" 2.1 .. לבחירתך..

לדעתי ה-ATP3 יותר איכותיים(לא בהרבה) , אבל בשביל חווית סראונד עדיף את ה-Inspire.

I have these two sets, you cant even compare... the ATP3 are more powerful and the sound is very clear, thanks to the fact they have two elements: the mid and the twiter, copmare to Inspire with only mid and it does makes the difference!

the Inspire are nice if you dont going to increase the volume too high.

Take in mind just one thing, the bass in the ATP3 is not muddy at all, its like boomy not so deep... but its a very subjective issue, if you can hear them before the purchase that will be very good !

Anyway Good luck with the choice ! 

נצל"ש.

באמת ההפרש במחיר (כיום 100 ש"ח) מצדיק את ההשקעה בקניית ה-ATP3 לעומת קניית ה-4400? למשל במקרה שלי, רוב הזמן אני לא אשתמש בווליום גבוה, ובד"כ אשים ווליום בינוני-נמוך... ההבדל באיכות בשבילי יהיה משמעותי? או שזה רק כשמדובר בעוצמה? ואיך בהשוואה הסאבים של המערכות הנ"ל?

חבל מאוד שהמחיר של ה-ATP3 עולה בזמן האחרון, לעומת ה-4400. יש מצב לרכוש את ה-ATP3 במחיר יותר נורמלי?

I have these two sets, you cant even compare... the ATP3 are more powerful and the sound is very clear, thanks to the fact they have two elements: the mid and the twiter, copmare to Inspire with only mid and it does makes the difference!

the Inspire are nice if you dont going to increase the volume too high.

Take in mind just one thing, the bass in the ATP3 is not muddy at all, its like boomy not so deep... but its a very subjective issue, if you can hear them before the purchase that will be very good !

Anyway Good luck with the choice ! 

So you're saying that that difference, when using a low volume, is really minor? If so, they are likely to be compareble in this case. And what about the subwoofer? Is the creative's one is kinda toy comparing to Altec's sub?

There is one more thing you should consider:

What do you need them for?

If just music, take the ATP3, you won't be sorry

If just games, take the 4400, nothing beats taking the light off and playing Doom or HL with surround sound (or even just driving in NFS, or getting the enviromental sounds in RPG games, people underestimate the surround feature)

If Movies, you should consider 5.1, as most of the speech and effects in the movies come from the center channel, and it sux watching a 5.1 AC3 movie with 4.1 speaker set.

Hope it helps.

So you're saying that that difference, when using a low volume, is really minor? If so, they are likely to be compareble in this case. And what about the subwoofer? Is the creative's one is kinda toy comparing to Altec's sub?

Not so minor, thay have just one element [mid] and it sound more simple, not accurate...

In both cases the Altec sounds much better, If surround is reaay important take the Inspire 4400, just take in mine that they will give surround only in games, not movies.

BTW, one more factor that has very big influence on the sound quality is the sound card.

Not so minor, thay have just one element [mid] and it sound more simple, not accurate...

In both cases the Altec sounds much better, If surround is reaay important take the Inspire 4400, just take in mine that they will give surround only in games, not movies.

BTW, one more factor that has very big influence on the sound quality is the sound card.

hmm.. why wont surround work in movies ? i think it will, only in 4 speakers instead of 5.. because AC3FILTER can make an output matrix for only 4 speakers, no ?

about the sound card.. i think it's not that big (unless you really have something ultra-old) i mean, it's only the DAC that can truelly effect it...

You will get surround in movies (4ch), but you will also feel the center channel is missing, the AC3Filter thing does move some of the center channel to the front R&L channels, but you can still feel it's only 4.1 and not a full 5.1

trust me, i got 4.1, and i'm probably going to buy 5.1 now only for movies (don't know how it will affect games)

my 4.1 rocks, the best set i ever had, but it's not 5.1

(it's a KINYO set, not something familier, saved some $$ and got great quality, got lucky )

היה לי קריאייטיב אינספיר 4400 , והחלפתי לאלטק 4121 !

אין מה להשוות האינספיר 4400 נשמעים כמו צעצועים , ביחס לאלטק

And the difference between the VS4121 to the ATP3 in the price is pretty big [relatively] and the sound has same quality\power.

Maybe the VS4121 have 1-2W extra but this is really minor !

אכפת לכם לכתוב בעברית בבקשה?

אני קצת חלש באנגלית :-\

בסדר, אין לי בעיה לעבור לעברית.

למען האמת אני לא חושב שזה יהיה כ"כ משמעותי בשבילי הסנטר בסרטים... אפשר לדעתי להסתפק איכשהו עם 4.1. כמו שכבר אמרתי, אני צריך רמקולים יותר לסרטים, אחרי זה מוזיקה, ולבסוף משחקים. כרגע ברשותי כ. קול - SB LIVE! VALUE - כלומר תומך עד 4.1 :-\ מה שבינתיים מונע ממני לקנות את ה-4400 זה שיש את ה-ATP3, שכנשמע מוציאים צליל איכותי יותר בהרבה. יש אולי איזו מערכת רמקולים 4.1 שמפיקה איכות דומה לשל ATP3? למשל כמו שהיה את ה-ATP5.